Sunday, 13 January 2013

How to generate ideas and solve problems

How to generate ideas and solve problems

Brainstorming

Brainstorming is a technique, developed by an American Advertising Executive, Alex Osborn in the 1930s. It is based on what we know of the brain’s physiology and operation. The latest thinking in neuroscience has poo poo'd the idea of a strict demarcation of function between the right and left hemispheres of the brain as it has been found that both sides are involved (in different ways and to differing degrees) with almost everything we do or think.  However, I'm going to use 'right = creativity' and 'left = objective rationality' as a sort of shorthand for the different mental processes of  generating ideas and evaluating those ideas.

Regarding the 'left brain' approach to evaluation - we are very good at spotting the weaknesses in our ideas pretty much straight away. This can become a powerful habit, with the left brain happily trashing every idea the right brain can throw at it. We have an internal monologue repeating ‘that’ll never work’ and before we know it, we’ve ‘run out of ideas’. In fact, the right brain has just become dispirited and given up! Plato told us that ‘necessity was the Mother of Invention’. Well then that makes ideas into infants and your left brain guilty of infanticide many times over, as it has snuffed out new born idea after new born idea!

This isn’t just an internal process - it is something that happens when groups of people come
together to discuss an issue or a problem. Teresa Amabile, Professor of Business Administration at Harvard Business School has asserted that ‘people believe that they will appear smarter ... if they are more critical ... In many organisations it is professionally rewarding to react critically to new ideas”.

Brainstorming works because:

* it forces the left brain (our own and that of other people) to suspend judgement, to shut up
for a while while the right brain does its work. Only when this process is completed do we
begin to evaluate.

* it suspends the culture of criticism referred to by Amabile, encouraging the acceptance of ideas
- at least temporarily.

Osborn spotted how ideas were often killed in meetings before they had a chance to develop. He
developed four simple rules to ensure that all ideas were able to survive long enough to ensure
proper debate and evaluation. These were:

1 Criticism is ruled out and judgement withheld until later.
2 Wild ideas are welcome.
3 Quantity is more important than quality.
4 Combination of ideas is good; in other words, building on and developing other people’s
ideas is just as important as coming up with new ones of your own.

Structured brainstorming - Radiant Thinking

In ‘The Power of Creative Intelligence’ Tony Buzan outlines the idea of Radiant Thinking. This idea is similar to Mind Mining, with one crucial difference - it offers a visual and tangible ‘map’ to ensure that your ideas are more systematically identified and captured. The fact that the technique helps us actually draw a map of our developing thoughts is vitally important to its effectiveness. In ‘Thinking Skills and Eye Q’, Caviglioli, Harris and Tindall assert that because of the central role sight has played in our survival and success as a species, we are hard wired to learn visually. ‘Show me’ rather than ‘tell me’ works better for most of us ... ‘when people can see what they are thinking, they immediately become better thinkers’ say the authors. And that is what radiant thinking does. It shows us the map of our ideas as they develop, stage by stage. In so doing it gives clarity to the relationships between facts, ideas, issues and so on, and allows us to free associate to look for answers or solutions.
An example of radiant thinking, wherein one starts with a single idea and then adds associated ideas can be found below. I tried this with a small charity working in London which needed a basis to begin looking for new ways to fundraise.

Step one: Start with a single idea, let’s say ‘Fundraising’. This is the Primary Concept. Create a
figure with the word in the middle, so:


Step 2: Radiate 5 ‘spokes’ away from the core idea, and write an associated idea along each of
these. These each represent a Secondary Concept. For example:

Business / Trusts / Community / Statutory  Individuals






Step 3: Next take each of the secondary branches and radiate 5 (or so) sub spokes from each of these.
Place ideas that you associate with the Secondary Concept along each of these branches. These
are the Tertiary Concepts.




This is a really quick way to exploit your mind’s natural ability to build connections and ‘map’, in
quick succession many ideas. The three step sequence above took only a few minutes and yet
produced 30 Tertiary fundraising ideas for further discussion. Specifically, the ideas looked like this ...

Business
Sponsorship - develop packages. Create a Gifts in Kind schedule. Use Chairperson’s connection.
Investigate Give As You Earn. Research local corporate HQs.
Trusts
Take training in proposal writing skills. Invite past donors to AGM. Develop supporting materials.
Create new ‘trust friendly’ projects. Get policy details of top 50 trusts with an interest in our
beneficiaries.
Community
Run a flag day. Contact all local schools. Ask local churches for Christmas donations
Get adopted as charity of the year by one major local employer. Enlist Student Union in
fundraising activities.
Statutory
Search Home Office web site. Invite Councillor Jones onto committee. Make presentation to full
Council . Check out Primary Care Trust funding. Secure one major contract.
Individuals
Undertake prospect listing session. Identify local high net worth ‘players’. Purge and update the
database. Profile the charity supporters more accurately. Launch legacy pack.

Below you can see a Mind Map designed by a delegate on a time management course run by the author.



Variation on a theme - Mindwriting

This idea is based on the Crawford Slip Method, first developed by C.C. Crawford at the University
of Southern California in 1925. The key difference is that participants are asked to make
contributions in writing instead of verbally.

This has a number of advantages:

* because all ideas are captured, there is less chance that the session facilitator or leader can
influence the outcome or place an emphasis on just some of the ideas generated (in a
conventional brainstorming or mindmining session it’s easy to move on quickly without writing
something up on a flip chart, either because you don’t fully understand it or you don’t really like
it. When this happens, it is not often challenged.)
* people may be less inhibited.
* if you keep the contributions anonymous before critically examining them, it takes ‘personality’
out of the equation. The ideas stand or fall on their own merit.



Hope you found this helpful and interesting!!




Friday, 11 January 2013

The Best Customer Care Story Ever

My favourite customer care story used to be the one about the old man who walked into JC Penney in New York and demanded the sum of $300 for car tyres he had purchased 5 years earlier.  His complaint was that they were now bald.  Despite the fact that he had no receipt or other proof of purchase, and that 5 years of motoring would tax the most robust of tyres - he was immediately given a full refund - no questions asked.  But what is really astonishing about this story is that JC Penney doesn't even sell car tyres!  Never has.

This story has been used by management trainers for years to epitomise the values and behaviours of customer focused organisations.  They are always right - even when they are dead wrong - and you have to do everything in your power to make them happy!

Last week I came across another story that gives the JC Penney tale a run for its money.  Making difficult customers happy is not always easy.  After all - they are difficult.  Some may even be evil.  But sometimes it can be done with wit, elegance and generosity of spirit - and in ways which cost you very little.  My new heroes are the people who make Lego.  When a little lad lost a treasured Lego action figure he wrote to the company.  I reproduce his letter, and their reply in full below.  Enjoy ...

"Hello.
My name is Luka Apps and I am seven years old.
With all my money I got for Christmas I bought the Ninjago kit of the Ultrasonic Raider. The number is 9449. It is really good.
My Daddy just took me to Sainsburys and told me to leave the people at home but I took them and I lost Jay ZX at the shop as it fell out of my coat.
I am really upset I have lost him. Daddy said to send you a email to see if you will send me another one.
I promise I won't take him to the shop again if you can.
– Luka"

 ____________________________________________

Luka, I told Sensei Wu that losing your Jay minifigure was purely an accident and that you would never ever ever let it happen ever again.
He told me to tell you, "Luka, your father seems like a very wise man. You must always protect your Ninjago minifigures like the dragons protect the Weapons of Spinjitzu!"
Sensei Wu also told me it was okay if I sent you a new Jay and told me it would be okay if I included something extra for you because anyone that saves their Christmas money to buy the Ultrasonic Raider must be a really big Ninjago fan.
So, I hope you enjoy your Jay minifigure with all his weapons. You will actually have the only Jay minifigure that combines 3 different Jays into one! I am also going to send you a bad guy for him to fight!
Just remember, what Sensei Wu said: keep your minifigures protected like the Weapons of Spinjitzu! And of course, always listen to your Dad.

The Lego Guys

Monday, 17 December 2012

Better late than never ...

I think I first sat down to write a blog about five years ago.  Then I got a bit busy, decided to finish it off tomorrow, one thing led to another and then - well then it was now.  

A lot has happened in the last five years of course. The bank bailout, the crash, the bonfire of the quangos, the coalition. We're all older, definitely a bit more bruised, but hopefully also a little bit wiser than we were back then.  And because of that this blog will be quite different from that originally envisaged.  My initial purpose was, I'll be frank, to sell more things to more customers.  Consultancy, fundraising, training, mentoring, bid writing, strategy, presentation skills, time management, project management, creativity and innovation - you name it, I had a smart blog post ready to push it to an unsuspecting world.   But that world is fundamentally different now.  Local authorities have taken a hammering, services have been cut, charities have had to step into the breach and work harder for less.  And on a more positive note, we are all more connected and have more on - line resources available than ever before.

This new blog will seek to add value to what we do at MBA by taking advantage of this growing interconnectedness.  I talk to a lot of people, all of the time, about the challenges they face and the solutions they employ.  I'd like to share some of that thinking.  Whether it is about fundraising, governance, strategic planning, becoming more entrepreneurial, earning money, government policy or anything else that crosses my radar - if I think it will help someone, my purpose will be to report upon it, summarise it, suggest it.  

Let's start with something for everyone interested in getting support from business during these troubled times.  It's an interesting article from the Institute of Leadership and Management on how business people seek to motivate employees by engaging in projects with social outcomes.  The point is made that these outcomes are usually somehow 'aligned' with the main thing the business does. How will this help you get support from a business? - well, your job is to creatively identify how your cause is aligned to the products, brand, location or customers of any given company.  If you can find this shared territory, you'll (to coin a phrase) be in business!  The article includes a couple of nice case studies and should provide food for thought.  Take a look:  http://www.i-l-m.com/edge/Create_a_workplace_buzz.aspx?utm_campaign=Edge+11+December+-+members%2C+subs+and+trial&utm_source=ILM